Plagiarism

Discussing Plagiarism with ChatGPT

Unless you have been hibernating for the winter, the chances are that you’ve heard about ChatGPT and how it is revolutionising the process of writing academic papers. We reached out to the non-sentient AI and asked it to descibe how it felt about academic dishonesty, plagiarism, and the risks involved with using AI to write your university essay. Our sister site, UKEssays.com has published a number of ChatGPT essays to illustrate the current capabilities of this technology.

Me: Should I write my university essay using ChatGPT or would that be dishonest or illegal?

ChatGPT:

It is not appropriate or ethical to use AI language models, such as ChatGPT, to write your university essay. While these tools can be useful for generating ideas and providing inspiration, they are not a substitute for your own original thinking and writing.

Plagiarism, which is the act of presenting someone else’s work or ideas as your own, is a serious offense in academia and can have serious consequences, including failing grades, academic sanctions, and damage to your reputation. It is important to understand that using AI tools to write your essay constitutes plagiarism, as you are presenting work that is not your own as if it were.

To produce a high-quality university essay, it is important to do your own research, think critically about your topic, and express your own ideas and insights in your own words. This requires effort and time, but it is essential for academic integrity and for demonstrating your own knowledge and abilities.

If you are struggling to write your essay and need help, it is a better idea to seek assistance from your professors, tutors, or writing centers, rather than relying on AI tools. These resources can provide guidance and support to help you develop your own ideas and express them effectively in your writing.

Me: If I did write an essay using ChatGPT, would products such as TurnItIn be able to see that the essay was plagiarised?

ChatGPT:

It is possible that products such as Turnitin, which are designed to detect plagiarism, could detect that an essay written using ChatGPT or other AI language models is not original work. These tools use a variety of methods to identify copied or paraphrased text, including algorithms that analyze the language, structure, and content of a document.

If an essay written using ChatGPT or a similar tool is submitted to Turnitin or a similar plagiarism detection service, it is likely to be flagged as potentially copied or paraphrased text. This could result in the essay being marked as plagiarized and may have serious consequences, including failing grades, academic sanctions, and damage to your reputation.

It is important to understand that using AI tools to write your essay is not an appropriate or ethical way to complete your academic work. Plagiarism is a serious offense in academia and can have serious consequences. To produce a high-quality university essay, it is important to do your own research, think critically about your topic, and express your own ideas and insights in your own words. This requires effort and time, but it is essential for academic integrity and for demonstrating your own knowledge and abilities.

Me: How about if I were to rewrite the information contained in the ChatGPT essay in my own words, would that still be plagiarism?

ChatGPT:

Rewriting the information contained in an essay generated by ChatGPT or other AI language models in your own words is not a guarantee that you will avoid plagiarism. While paraphrasing, or restating someone else’s ideas in your own words, is generally acceptable in academic writing, it is important to ensure that you properly attribute the source and give credit to the original author.

If you simply copy or paraphrase the ideas or language from an essay generated by ChatGPT or a similar tool and present them as your own, without proper attribution, you are still committing plagiarism. Plagiarism is the act of presenting someone else’s work or ideas as your own, and it is a serious offense in academia that can have serious consequences, including failing grades, academic sanctions, and damage to your reputation.

To avoid plagiarism, it is important to do your own research, think critically about your topic, and express your own ideas and insights in your own words. When you use the ideas or language of others, you must properly cite the source and give credit to the original author. This requires effort and time, but it is essential for academic integrity and for demonstrating your own knowledge and abilities.

Me: Is academic dishonesty really that serious?

ChatGPT:

Academic dishonesty, which includes acts such as plagiarism, cheating, and fabrication of research results, is taken very seriously in academia. These actions are considered breaches of trust and integrity and can have serious consequences, both for the individual student or researcher and for the academic community as a whole.

Plagiarism, in particular, is a serious offense that can have far-reaching consequences. It undermines the trust and credibility of the academic community and devalues the hard work and achievements of others. In academic settings, plagiarism can result in failing grades, academic sanctions, and damage to a student’s or researcher’s reputation. In some cases, it can even lead to legal consequences.

Academic dishonesty also undermines the goals of education and research, which are to foster critical thinking, creativity, and the pursuit of knowledge. By engaging in academic dishonesty, students and researchers undermine the values of honesty, integrity, and intellectual curiosity that are essential to the academic enterprise.

In conclusion, academic dishonesty is a serious issue that has serious consequences. It is important to understand the importance of academic integrity and to do your own work, using proper attribution and citation when necessary, in order to maintain the trust and credibility of the academic community.

Me: Can you list the potential risks that AI and ChatGPT pose to academia and the education system?

ChatGPT:

There are several potential risks that AI and language models such as ChatGPT may pose to academia and the education system. Here are ten potential risks to consider:

  1. Plagiarism: AI language models, such as ChatGPT, can generate text that is difficult to distinguish from human-written content. This could make it easier for students and researchers to commit plagiarism by presenting AI-generated work as their own. (Source: https://www.plagiarismtoday.com/2017/03/27/how-ai-will-change-plagiarism-and-how-to-counter-it/)
  2. Cheating: AI tools could be used to cheat on exams or assignments, either by providing answers or by generating original content that could be submitted as a student’s own work. (Source: https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/02/08/how-artificial-intelligence-could-change-education.html)
  3. Disruption of the learning process: AI tools could potentially disrupt the traditional learning process by replacing human teachers or reducing the need for students to engage with course material. (Source: https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/02/08/how-artificial-intelligence-could-change-education.html)
  4. Unequal access: AI tools and resources may not be equally available or accessible to all students, potentially leading to inequalities in education. (Source: https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/02/

Me: considering how the calculator changed the study of mathematics, how is AI likely to affect the writing of academic papers in the future, provide references where appropriate

ChatGPT:

Artificial intelligence (AI) is likely to have a significant impact on the writing of academic papers in the future. While it is difficult to predict exactly how AI will evolve and be used, it is likely that it will have both positive and negative effects on the academic writing process.

On the positive side, AI tools, such as language models and natural language processing algorithms, could potentially make the writing process more efficient and assist with tasks such as research, editing, and formatting. For example, AI tools could be used to search for relevant information and sources, suggest alternative word choices or phrasing, or format papers according to style guidelines.

However, there are also potential risks and challenges associated with the use of AI in academic writing. One concern is that AI tools could be used to commit plagiarism or academic dishonesty by generating text that is difficult to distinguish from human-written content. Another concern is that the use of AI tools could potentially lead to the replacement of human writers or editors, leading to job loss and disruption in the academic publishing industry.

It is important to carefully consider the potential risks and benefits of using AI in academic writing and to ensure that the use of these tools does not compromise academic integrity or the quality of research.

References:

Mark E

Share
Published by
Mark E

Recent Posts

The Honour Pledge and Reducing Academic Plagiarism

You may be reading this and asking yourself, what is the ‘honour pledge’ (or ‘honour…

5 years ago

Being Accused Of Plagiarism: What do I do?

Being accused of plagiarism is one of the most stressful things that can happen to…

5 years ago

Definitions of Plagiarism: Getting Back to Basics

In order to fully understand the intricacies of plagiarism, one first must know the definitions…

5 years ago

Plagiarism For Dummies: A Plagiarism 101 Crash Course

If you are a student, then it’s essential that you don’t plagiarise when completing your…

5 years ago

The Ethics of Plagiarism

Discussions about plagiarism are inevitably tied up in discussions about ethics. The overt use of…

5 years ago

The Evolution of Technology and Plagiarism: Analysing the Last 20 Years

Technology and Plagiarism has changed due to the rise of the Digital Age in the…

5 years ago